156 – Genosha Strikes Back

Art by David Wynne. Contact David to purchase the original!

In which we hit the Empire Strikes Back of X-Tinction Agenda; it’s hard to be Laura Kinney; the psychic knife makes its debut; Evil!Sexy Moira retains some moral high ground; if your society is built on slavery, your society deserves to crumble; words mean things; Havok would be a terrible housecat; the mutants do not have the patent on stupidity; the opposite of blades is cotton; we give Cameron Hodge’s severed head a pep talk; and Cyclops goes full Peralta.

X-PLAINED:

  • Uncanny X-Men #271, New Mutants #96, X-Factor #61
  • Laura Kinney’s brief babysitting career
  • Our upcoming hiatus
  • Dramatis personae
  • A figurative battering ram
  • Focused totality
  • Best insults of the 1990s
  • A debate
  • Ethics of rhetoric
  • Housecat Havok
  • Skittering
  • Mutate numbering systems
  • The Prisoner vs. Les Miserables
  • The slow disintegration of reality as we know it
  • Sneaking with Cable
  • A singularly anticlimactic cover
  • A lushly illustrated report
  • Increasingly petty revenge
  • S.H.I.E.L.D.’s most advanced bald cap
  • A rising storm
  • Art teams
  • What we’d like to see out of an X-Men cinematic reboot

NEXT EPISODE: Return of the Revenge of the X-Men


You can find the visual companion to this episode on our blog.

Find us on iTunes or Stitcher!

Jay and Miles X-Plain the X-Men is 100% ad-free and listener supported. If you want to help support the podcast–and unlock more cool stuff–you can do that right here!

We’re in the process of migrating our official shop to TeePublic! Click over to check it out! (You can still find the designs we haven’t moved yet at Redbubble.)

28 comments

  1. Damien says:

    Should I take a drink because Jay quoted Rocketeer?

  2. Icon_UK says:

    Please tell me that at some point, possibly in PAD’s run, there is a discussion about Alex having a chronic BO problem, just so they can keep talk about “reeking Havok”.

    (Sorry, it’s a Monday morning and my brain goes to the strangest places when I’m commuting)

    Oh, and just to note that David Wynne is KILLING it with his episode cover pieces for this crossover!

    • Gary says:

      RE: PAD and “reeking Havok”.

      It is not inside of his initial X-Factor run, and I don’t believe he ever writes Alex in X-Factor after that.

      “Oh, and just to note that David Wynne is KILLING it with his episode cover pieces for this crossover!”

      Yes, he is. While I disagree that Hodge ever looked creepy during X-Tinction Agenda, David Wynne’s episode picture for this episode is disconcerting.

      • RaikoLives says:

        Actually PAD gets to write Alex a bit more. He turns up in X-Factor’s Investigation years (Volume 3, I think, technically) after he, Lorna and Rachel come back from dealing with Vulcan in space, and Alex briefly leads the team while Madrox is dead. He then breaks up with Polaris and leaves to go lead the Avengers Unity Squad. Ugh. I wish he’d stayed.

        Mr David THEN gets to write Alex just a LITTLE more during All-New X-Factor (which would be Volume 4, I guess) as Havok uses Quicksilver to spy on Lorna for him (remember, at this point, he and Polaris were technically half-brother and sister). So Pietro goes and talks to Alex from time to time to fill him in on things, meaning they get to share a few scenes in bars playing pool, which is cool.

        I still don’t think there’s a “reeking Havok” joke in there, sadly.

    • Devin says:

      I’m trying to think who would most make that joke. I’m not as familiar with David’s X-Factor era (I understand this is a failing of mine), but I could totally see Bobby saying it at some point in a hypothetical crossover.

  3. ray says:

    I remember this crossover started the whole “too many characters in one comics” for me, and thus much less effective then it should’v been. Still better from most of the crossover that came later though. The fact that Archangel didn’t have any meaningful arc in this, knowing what this villiain means for him, totally bummed me off.
    But you do manage to throw the light on whatever worked and was good in this story.
    I think it would’v worked better with more issues, being long as AoA maybe, but such effort – following and combining three different series into this one story – would probably be on the verge of impossible, and would resolt on a total unreadable mess if it was to be tried out. Still it’s a thing worth dreaming about. Imagine a story with the scale of the crossover and the character approach of every regular comics. The only thing I can think of that achievied this is the Dark Phoenix Saga – and it had much less characters then any regular crossover today. Makes you think how you can achive this kind of thing on the modern comics platform…

    • CitizenX says:

      It’s funny you mention Archangel not really having meaningful interaction with Hodge. I only read the last two X-Factor issues and none of the New Mutants issues when this came out. Uncanny X-Men gives us little indication that Hodge had any real history with any of these characters. He just came across as the mutant hater in charge of Genosha.

  4. Nate says:

    You have no idea how happy I was to hear the score from ending of Empire Strikes Back because oddly enough when I was getting into X-Men about 14 years ago that was the one CD that I always listened to. The Cloud City theme from Empire will always be associated with both the Morlocks Mister Sinister and Han and Leia’s love theme will always be Scott and Jean’s.

  5. PopeBelligerent says:

    Didn’t the whole “Wolverine gets turned into an evil assassin by the Hand” thing kinda end up playing out in Enemy of the State?

    • David says:

      Yeah, although it’s pretty close to an ironclad law of physics that Chris Claremont’s version of that story would’ve been better than Mark Millar’s. Likewise, Death of Wolverine seems to play out the same sort of arc that he envisioned for the run-up to X-Men vol. 2 #3.

  6. Gary says:

    Was there a production problem with the audio for this episode? Miles was very quiet compared to Jay, to the point where I was having to repeatedly adjust the volume as they bantered back and forth (I finally wound up just living with loud Jay). It’s not an uncommon problem for many podcasts I listen to, but it is an uncommon problem for this one, so, I ask.

    • Miles says:

      Weird – I didn’t notice that when I proofed the episode. I’ll check on it, but – what app / site / etc. are you using to listen to the episode?

      • Gary says:

        Podcast Addict.

        • Miles says:

          I’ve tried in a few places, but I haven’t been able to reproduce the issue. I don’t have access to an Android device to try Podcast Addict, though – maybe it’s an issue with that app, or maybe with the audio balance of your audio setup since Jay and I have different pitches to our voices?

          I wish I could help more, but thank you for letting us know, and I’ll keep poking at it!

          • Gary says:

            Thanks for looking into it. I’ve listened to probably 40-60 episodes on exactly this setup, and have never had it happen before.

    • ray says:

      I didn’t have any problem. It might be in the software you’re using.

  7. Jeff says:

    Great episode as always.

    I have to agree with Miles that I never bought into the Wolverine/Jean Grey thing, at least not early on. The idea of the best there is at what he does pining longingly after one of the strangest teens of all — who was FINALLY committed to her teen sweetheart — rang false to me. I get a Wolverine crush — we’ve all had a crush on a 20-year-old redhead (I married mine) but the reciprocity always rang false to me.

    Speaking of Wolverine… the whole “Wolverine is dying thing” is an example of good continuity … Wolverine has not been top notch since his crucification. There were a few issues of “Alpha Flight” at roughly this same time where he went to Canada to say goodbye to Heather because he figured he was dying. Not a great time in Alpha’s history but still a nice touch. Also where Alpha Flight find out the X-Men are still alive after Fall of the Mutants, for the record.

    I loved the penciler/inker/colorist conversation at the end. Made me think of the famous scene in “Chasing Amy” (tracer!) but a good inker can make or break a penciler and even vastly change their style. One example is John Byrne self-inking on “Fantastic Four,” “Alpha Flight” and “Avengers West Coast” vs being inked by Terry Austin on the classic “X-Men” run … yeah you can make out the recognizable “Byrne faces” but stylistically it’s very different. My favorite example though is Kirby. If you look at old “Thor” issues there is a vast difference between the thick lines of Chic Stone’s inks to the rather sketchier but more subtle lines of Vince Colletta. In fact if you look at later “Thor,” when Keith Pollard is drawing the book during both the Thomas era and the Gruenwald/Macchio/Moench era, Pollard’s work looks VERY Kirby-ish thanks to inks by Chic Stone.

    Miles btw — thanks for responding to my Thor tweet recently, looking forward to your new podcast.

  8. Devin says:

    I love Elle’s take as far as movies go, but I’d really love to see X-Men as a TV show, since it’d allow the soapiness to shine in all its sudsy glory. I’d honestly actually prefer something that takes certain ideas from the comics but plays a lot with it to create something new. Like, one of the things I’ve enjoyed so much about the CW shows is that it’s not just adapting an existing story or even typical character beats. Green Arrow’s arch-enemy is Deathstroke? Cool, why not? And we’re gonna make teh ultimate ship between him and a character tangentially inspired by Firestorm’s stepmom. Sure. Oh, and Flash’s bff’s are Killer Frost and Vibe, but they’re not gonna have those identities for a while.

    Also, let’s be real, only on TV will they even have the slightest realistic chance of making room for Super Doctor Astronaut Peter Corbeau in all his Super Doctor Astronaut Glory (as well as explore more of the side characters such as Stevie Hunter, a Moira who keeps tons of agency, etc.)

    As for the actual podcast episode, stellar as always. And as last week’s comment said, yes, I thought of the Mighty Monarch too.

  9. How was that Beast/”Beast” line NOT a Peter David line?! Signed, a fan of Peter David

  10. Josh says:

    It’s obvious to me that Hodge doesn’t skitter from place to place. Instead, he rides around on a Royalton Industries Segway to get from place to place.

    Imagine a world where Cameron Hodge is a VP at Royalton Industries…

  11. Alan Scott says:

    No Prize re: “literal poetry in motion”

    it’s not the metaphor that’s being described as literal. It’s the poetry. So Psylock is *figuratively* poetry in motion, but the particular poetry she’s being compared to within the metaphor is itself literal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *